Skip to content

Site Risk Summary

The first section of the PDF report is a short summary table of potential site risks. It is designed as a quick checklist: each row is a single check based on the other outputs of the analysis, with a status of Risk, No risk detected or Not assessed, and a short detail line showing the measured value and the threshold used.

A flagged risk does not mean a site is unsuitable for restoration. It highlights something in the data that should be looked at more closely, on the relevant map layer, and checked against local knowledge and field data. Equally, "No risk detected" only means this specific check did not trigger, not that the site is free of that risk.

The connected tidal zone

All of the checks only consider the connected tidal zone: the intertidal pixels (2% to 80% inundation, the same zone used for Tidal Connectivity) that also have a tidal connectivity index above 0.6. This ensures the risks are only checked for areas of the site which have intertidal inundation rates and a consistent pattern of inundation. Areas of deep water, dry land and disconnected ponds, channels and lakes are ignored. It is possible, if the AOI does not capture much of the true intertidal zone or if the site is dominated by non-tidal water, that this check will select a non intertidal area, so the outputs should always be checked for validity.

The report states what percentage of intertidal pixels fall within the connected tidal zone, which itself acts as a check for overall site tidal connectivity.

The checks

Risk Flagged when Based on
Erosion and coastal dynamics There is a contiguous region of 10 or more pixels (0.1 ha) with a significant erosion or sedimentation trend steeper than ±0.1 per year Erosion/sedimentation indication
Exposure There is a contiguous region of 50 or more pixels (0.5 ha) with a wind wave exposure index above 1,000,000 m³/s² Wind & Swell Exposure
Natural establishment No pixel in the connected tidal zone had a window of opportunity for mangrove establishment in at least half of the years assessed Effective Wave Height & Establishment Season
Tide model suitability The average tidal correlation over the connected tidal zone is 0.7 or lower Tidal Correlation
Tidal connectivity Fewer than 95% of intertidal pixels have a tidal connectivity index above 0.6 Tidal Connectivity

Contiguous regions include pixels touching diagonally.

A check is shown as Not assessed when the layer it depends on could not be calculated for the site, for example if there were not enough satellite scenes to estimate tidal connectivity, or if the wind data could not be retrieved.

Interpreting each risk

  • Erosion and coastal dynamics. A sizeable area within the connected tidal zone has become noticeably wetter (possible erosion) or drier (possible sedimentation) over the trend period. Check the erosion/sedimentation layer to see where and in which direction. This indicates a highly dynamic site. A dynamic coastline itself is not an indication that it is not suitable for mangrove restoration, however it indicates that areas of the site are changing quickly and this should be clearly understood before proposing site interventions.
  • Exposure. Part of the connected tidal zone is exposed to strong wind-generated waves over long fetches. Exposed intertidal areas such as open beaches are often unsuitable for mangrove establishment, even where the inundation and connectivity look suitable. As the wave energy assessment method does not account for wave attenuation from shallow water or reefs, this is often a very conservative estimate, and it is quite possible that site conditions indicate lower wave energy on the shoreline. If the site has high wind and long fetch however, there should be additional justification that it is sheltered enough for mangroves. Check the Effective Wave Height & Establishment Season page for a more detailed assessment of wave conditions. Che
  • Natural establishment. Wave conditions in the connected tidal zone rarely stay calm enough for long enough for stranded seedlings to establish: no area had a window of opportunity in at least half of the years assessed. Natural recruitment is unlikely in most years, and planted seedlings may also struggle without wave protection. Again, this is a conservative estimate that does not account for shallow water or other forms of wave attenuation, and has the same limitations as the wind swell risk check. See the Effective Wave Height & Establishment Season page for when windows do occur.
  • Tide model suitability. The modelled tide does not closely match the observed inundation in the connected tidal zone. Tide model based outputs, such as the Tidal Cycle, should be treated with caution, and local water level data is recommended. This has no impact on the suitability of the site for mangroves, however it will affect the validity of other analyses. If using satellite data for growth monitoring or dynamic baselining, and relying on tide model data to remove high water scenes, then an unsuitable tide model would mean that this tidal screening of satellite data would not work. Additionally, an unsuitable tide model indicates that tide model based risk assessments (storm surges, flooding risks) are also less accurate without site data for validation.
  • Tidal connectivity. A substantial part of the intertidal zone does not show a clear tidal connection, which may indicate levees, blocked channels, ponds with controlled water flow, or other disruptions to tidal flow. This also includes pixels with too few wet or dry observations to estimate tidal connectivity at all, so very cloudy sites or short date ranges can also trigger this risk.

Limitations & sources of error

  • Fixed thresholds. The thresholds are general screening values and not site-specific limits. Local site knowledge and data can be used to inform more precise thresholds, backed up with local measurements for higher confidence.
  • Depends on the input area. The connected tidal zone is defined relative to the input AOI (see Tidal Connectivity), so an AOI that covers little open intertidal area will give less meaningful results.
  • Inherits the limitations of each layer. Each risk is dependent on the associated results layer validity, see the linked pages for their individual limitations.

Site risks and mangroves

The risk summary can be considered a starting point for site investigations. The flagged risks indicate that there is evidence against the site's suitability for restoration, and they should be specifically addressed either through site data or thorough, site and condition specific justification before deciding on a restoration intervention.